Creative COW SIGN IN :: SPONSORS :: ADVERTISING :: ABOUT US :: CONTACT US
Creative COW's LinkedIn GroupCreative COW's Facebook PageCreative COW on TwitterCreative COW's Google+ PageCreative COW on YouTube
BLOGS:My COW BlogMacWorldEditingTechnologyAfter EffectsFinal CutEntertainment

FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...

COW Blogs : Steve Modica's Blog : FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
Recently, we’ve heard a lot of folks saying that it’s not possible to share projects or media files between multiple workstations using Final Cut Pro X. We asked Mark Ferris of Blue Ox Pictures to put this claim to the test, and here he explains that it’s simply not true:

I’m using one of Small Tree’s shared storage products and Final Cut Pro X and have no problems sharing data. While it’s true that Final Cut Pro X will not show mounted storage volumes in either the Event library or the Project library they can still be shared between workstations.
Here’s how I’m doing it:

First, go to the Utilities folder and open Apple’s Disk Utility. Under the File menu choose New>Blank Disk Image. Select the drive to save it to (the Desktop is the default) and give it a unique name. Under Size select Custom and make it as large as you can – it cannot be larger than the drive you’re saving it to. Even though the actual media files will reside on the Small Tree shared storage, the Render Files will be saved to the Disk Image, so it could get quite large. Now, under Image Format select Sparse Disk Image. By selecting this option the Disk Image will only be as large as the files it contains, and will grow to include additional files added to it until it reaches the Custom Size you entered a moment ago. So if your Custom Size is 500 GB but your Disk Image only contains 2 GB of media, it will only take up 2 GB of space on your drive. Click Create and your new Disk Image automatically mounts.

Launch Final Cut Pro X and the Disk Image will appear in both the Event and Project Libraries. Select the Disk Image in the Event Library and hit Option+N to create a new Event. Now select the Disk Image in the Project Library and hit Command+N to create a New Project. It’s a good idea to give them both the same name as the Disk Image, but any unique name should work fine.
Now select File>Import>Files and locate the folder on the Small Tree shared storage volume containing your media files. You want to Add them to Existing Event and choose the Event you just created. Uncheck Copy Files to Final Cut Events Folder, make sure Create Optimized Media and Create Proxy Media are also unchecked, and then click Import. If you open the Final Cut Events Folder on the Disk Image you’ll see that Final Cut has created an Alias to each of the media files on the shared storage - note the files have a Quicktime icon with a little arrow in the corner.

Edit your project. When you’re done use the Finder to copy the Disk Image to the Small Tree shared storage.

When another editor in another edit suite wants to work on this project he/she simply copies the Disk Image to a local drive, mounts it, and then opens Final Cut Pro X. The Events and Projects should be online and ready to edit. When finished, use the Finder to copy the Disk Image back to the Small Tree shared storage again.

Finally, a bit of bad news. If you use Motion 5 to customize a template in the Effects, Transitions, Titles, Generators or Themes Browser, the new template gets saved locally in the Movies>Motion Templates directory so Final Cut can find it. You do not have the option of saving it anywhere else. This new template will need to be copied manually from one workstation to another.

Posted by: Steve Modica on Jul 29, 2011 at 1:56:14 pmComments (9) FCPX, Smalltree
Reply   Like  

Comments

Re: Blog: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Eric Hansen
wow, that's way worse than I was hoping for.

right now i'm working on a movie, TV show, multiple teasers, web videos and DVD Extras, all pulling from the same ~30TB of media. it looks like FCP X will never be an option to even consider, no matter how many third party plug-ins are developed. Apple really messed this up for anyone with a shop with more than one computer, or more than one project.

e

Eric Hansen - http://www.erichansen.tv
Re: Blog: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Bob Zelin
Hi Eric -
true - unless some miracle happens, FCP X will never be an option.

As it is, many people can't stand volume based shared storage systems, because they don't want to think "gee, who has write access, and what do I have to do to turn off his write access, so I can get write access". And this is NOTHING compared to the "too many steps" required to get FCP X to work. (I personally have no issue with volume based shared storage).

As I observe, people will stick with FCP 7 (for now) and slowly migrate to either AVID or Adobe Premier. Who knows - maybe Apple will come out with a revision - I can't imagine that they are "giving away" XSAN licenses now, and just did this knowing that it would never work with FCP X. They are not stupid - so something is up their sleeve.

Bob Zelin

Re: Blog: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Andrew Richards
[Bob Zelin] "Who knows - maybe Apple will come out with a revision - I can't imagine that they are "giving away" XSAN licenses now, and just did this knowing that it would never work with FCP X. They are not stupid - so something is up their sleeve. "

There is some evidence that something is up their sleeves right there in the frameworks of the app.

Best,
Andy
Re: Blog: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Bob Zelin
interesting read. That is good digging, Andrew.

Bob

Re: Blog: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Andrew Richards
[Bob Zelin] "That is good digging, Andrew."

Alex did the digging, I just posted the link! ;-)

He has a few other interesting articles based on what he found buried in those frameworks.

Best,
Andy
Re: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Brent Hilgenkamp
Instead of copying the disk image to and from workstations, is it possible to just mount the image from the shared storage? Wouldn't this accomplish the same thing but without the steps of copying?
Re: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Steve Modica
[Brent Hilgenkamp] "Instead of copying the disk image to and from workstations, is it possible to just mount the image from the shared storage? Wouldn't this accomplish the same thing but without the steps of copying?"

I've done this and it works, although it's a little like editing a project file right from a public directory. It's not a real good idea.

I would call the scenario we outlined in this thread a phase I take on the issue. I'm sure apple is planning additional features (like xml import and export) that will change this. Before I go nuts on this, I'm waiting to see what those changes are.

Steve

Steve Modica
CTO, Small Tree Communications
Re: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Richard Harrington
With enough workarounds.. anything is possible...

But that's a lot more work than what I have going on today with other NLEs

Richard M. Harrington, PMP

Author: From Still to Motion, Video Made on a Mac, Photoshop for Video, Understanding Adobe Photoshop, Final Cut Studio On the Spot and Motion Graphics with Adobe Creative Suite 5 Studio Techniques
Re: FCPX Sharing? Sure you can...
by Jason Whetstone
Thanks for sharing this workaround. As for sharing Motion templates, you could use a synchronize program to accomplish this pretty easily. Chronosync has a server/client solution that could work well for that. You really could do it on your own with a bit of folder actions/AppleScript/bash wizardry.


Steve Modica's place to pontificate.
Blog FeedRSS


FORUMSTUTORIALSMAGAZINESTOCKYARDVIDEOSPODCASTSEVENTSSERVICESNEWSLETTERNEWSBLOGS

Creative COW LinkedIn Group Creative COW Facebook Page Creative COW on Twitter
© 2012 CreativeCOW.net All rights are reserved. - Privacy Policy

[Top]