Creative COW SIGN IN :: SPONSORS :: ADVERTISING :: ABOUT US :: CONTACT US :: FAQ
Creative COW's LinkedIn GroupCreative COW's Facebook PageCreative COW on TwitterCreative COW's Google+ PageCreative COW on YouTube
BLOGS:My COW BlogAdobe BlogMacWorldEditingTechnologyAfter EffectsFinal CutEntertainment

Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet

COW Blogs : Kylee Wall's Blog : Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
Share on Facebook
USE THE PEN.

From the moment I stepped in the door at BCM, that's all I heard from Walter. It was like a nerdier version of Obi Wan Kenobi. (Is that possible?) My work station is equipped with a Wacom Intuos 4 (I think) -- which is very nice, both the product and the fact it was sitting there.

(And note to Walter: it was LIKE Obi Wan, I didn't say you actually ARE Obi Wan.)

But man, talk about tablet-challenged. The first time I picked up a pen and tried to do anything, I was dragging crap all over and misclicking and things were catching on fire. NO. WHY. STOP. Adjusting to a new job and state and like I don't know LIFE IN GENERAL is hard enough without taking away my mouse, my most basic human comfort. I bailed.

Seriously, what's so fab about it?



Two months later, this week, I decided to give it a fair shot. I asked for advice on Twitter for getting a handle on...handling it. The most useful tip came from Shane Ross.



Turns out there are a lot of you tablet editors lurking out there. Who knew asking about editing on a Wacom would bring all you geeks out of hiding?







So this past Monday morning at 9:30AM, I loaded up my project in Premiere Pro CC, put my mouse aside, and committed to pen only existence for a whole week.

At about 9:45AM, I had irreversibly screwed up my workspace in Premiere. I have no idea what I did -- probably dragged something somewhere somehow -- but my stuff went all bananas and I spent 15 minutes getting it back the way I wanted it.

By afternoon, I was getting the hang of it. Sorta. It wasn't frustrating me to the point of throwing it, but I was swearing quite a bit as I acclimated to its sensitivity. It ended up feeling more natural more quickly than I had anticipated, to be honest. I use the keyboard very heavily for everything and when my right hand isn't doing anything, it sits on my mouse. Hangs out there, chillin. With the pen, I avoid having it sitting in an awkward position for an extended period. I also don't have to put down the pen to do what my right hand does. I would show you my Premiere keyboard, but the keyboard shortcuts are seemingly impossible to share. It's very Avid-y with a strong dose of FCP7.

A thing I struggled with occasionally was dragging sliders in the effects window, or dragging graphics in the timeline. I grab and move around lower thirds and stuff all the time in my sequence, and just use snap to get them where I need them. When I "let go" of a graphic or something, the pen is so sensitive that it doesn't land where I want it to go, but a few frames to the left or right. So that's incredibly irritating. But at the same time, snapping stuff with a mouse in Premiere is also frustrating. I don't think it would be an issue so much in Media Composer, at least not with the stuff I usually cut in there. Plus, selecting trim points is different, so a lot of those issues wouldn't be relevant.



I expected this to be a fairly colorful blog post with a lot of censored swear words and hilarity about accidentally deleting entire volumes of work, but unfortunately for you (and fortunately for me) this was not the case. By Wednesday I wasn't having much of a problem. My brain was starting to deal with the oddities of the tablet and pen and compensate for them. I even did some cutting with a producer alongside without swearing at the pen AT ALL. Or doing anything stupid.

I know, huge accomplishment. For me, anyway.

A stupid thing I keep doing is putting the pen down and losing it. It's black, the desk is black, and it's dark. GREAT. Another stupid thing I keep doing is reaching for the mouse. That's some difficult muscle memory to break. I'm reaching for a mouse with a pen in my hand. More stupid muscle memory: getting use to putting the pen down and being in that part of the screen, rather than the motion of mousing your mouse to the area you want to go. All ridiculous when you write it down, but shut up, you try it and you'll see what I mean.

In terms of ACTUAL challenges besides the sensitivity being too sensitive at times, I found that OS X (and I'm sure every other operating system) isn't really conducive to a tablet. The clicking areas are very tiny and the dock is on the edge of the screen which kind of sucks. I navigate a lot of OS X with the keyboard as well -- command-spacebar to Spotlight to apps to launch, for example. I've always been kinda 50/50 on switching apps, doing it the hard way (click in the dock), but actually using the keyboard shortcut has become vital with the Wacom. It's a pain to go click in the dock. Command-tab brings up the app switching thingy so you can tab over to the app you want to jump to. It's so much faster and less annoying.

But being in the Finder itself is kinda crappy. Bringing in files via the Media Browser in Premiere is definitely the way to go most of the time anyway, but especially with the tablet. Big chunky squares begging to be clicked.

So alright, I guess I'm committing to the thing, I should figure out what these function buttons and stuff actually do, right? I've remapped the everloving hell out of my keyboard settings in all my NLEs to make myself more efficient, so mo' buttons mo' problems.

I found



. Unfortunately, it seems to have been designed by someone who has never actually been an editor in their entire lives. Yo, Wacom, look at all these psychopaths that literally PREACH THE RELIGION of the pen. Why don't you ask one of them to make you a video that editors can learn stuff from?

So I turned to Twitter to see what the hivemind likes. There's actually very little consensus about how to use the various buttons. Everybody is different. Paul Conigliaro (@conigs) had a very helpful and cute little gif instructing me in my grip to switch between pen and keyboard rapidly.

And a lot of people had other things to say.









A thing I learned about the Intuos4 was that it introduced Precision Mode, which seems to have solved my issues with moving around things with frame accuracy. Grab something, hit precision mode, drag, let go, hit precision mode. It's a little bit to get used to, but in some ways gets even more precise than the mouse. I can imagine that drawing masks with the thing gets straight up cray. I actually WANT to mask something and try it out. Eh. Kind of.



Additionally, I got a few tips from Dan Wolfmeyer who is in Media Composer on the Intuos 3.




But then I wonder if coming to rely on a tablet setup is wise. What if you end up in an edit room without a mouse, on a freelance gig or something? Will you adapt so closely to a pen that mousing will send you back to the stone ages in terms of efficiency? Will using a mouse after all this tablet Wacom pen junk turn your hand into a CLAW?

Kidding aside, I think this is a valid concern for people. Especially those who aren't particularly adaptable by nature. Is it possible to be tied too closely to a specified way of pointing around?

(I've been told that freelancers take their tablets with them from job to job with no issue, so there you go. I guess if you're in a corporate environment where they don't like new things or don't want you to change edit rooms, that might be a minor issue, but for the most part it's not a thing.)



Obviously I'm not too worried about it.

Anyway, here's where my tablet settings have ended up after a week of usage. I actually have double click and precision mode on the pen itself. I'm too used to control-clicking to right click anyway, so there's no point in trying to retrain some serious muscle memory when my left hand is on the keyboard anyway. On the tablet itself, somewhat untouched button arrangement. The wheel is mapped to J and L, and also left arrow and right arrow and zoom. I did end up with snap, hand tool, application switching, and right click. All of those things are done by my left hand on the regular, but I figured if I'm in an instance where I'm using the wheel heavily, it might not be terrible to not have to return to the keyboard for something. I'm not sure I ever will though. I'm like a trained monkey on the keyboard.




I guess I'll keep it up and see what happens. I've been known to get severe muscle cramps in my mouse hand, so I'm looking forward to not having cramps in my mouse hand. There's still a lot I don't know, especially about different tips (EH?).




And of course, if anyone has any suggestions or advice about this matter, please throw it in while my mind is still impressionable. There's a small window where I can train myself, know what I mean? So here's what I learned so far:

1. My hand doesn't hurt. It didn't really before, but it doesn't now either.
2. I am capable of learning new ways to point and click.
3. I'm going to lose the pen a lot.

I can't say it makes me any faster, but it doesn't seem to be slowing me down and it makes me LOOK a lot cooler, which we all know I desperately need.



(Only partially related note I accidentally found while Googling something else: Wacom is a Japanese portmanteau: Wa for "harmony" or "circle", and Komu for "computer". THAT'S SO CUTE.)

Posted by: Kylee Wall on Aug 9, 2013 at 4:13:48 pmComments (8) wacom pen tablet, video editing
Reply   Like  
Share on Facebook

Comments

Re: Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
by Cory Ginsburg
Been using one for a handful of months now and I'll never go back.
- disabled the tip so I don't have to worry about "clicking" if I touch the pad (which I do all the time)
- bottom pen button is single click
- top pen button is R-click
this way it functions essentially just like a mouse, but 100 times more comfortable. I also mapped the tablet area smaller so that with a flick of the wrist I can move from edge of left monitor to edge of right monitor without lifting my hand.
Re: Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
by Jon Zanone
I'm wondering how using a tablet works for a lefty? It looks like almost every tablet I've looked at is designed for a righty.

Be curious, not judgmental.
Walt Whitman

@Jon Zanone
by Jon Zanone
OK, so it's early... I guess you just turn the tablet upside down?
Re: Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
by Patrice Freymond
I've used a Wacom for over 20 years for editing and can't imagine not to. As a freelancer I moved about town with my tablet and installed it everywhere I went.

Getting used to it was kind of easy as my first computers were all laptops; I therefore went through various pointer controls such a track balls, track pads and evnt that red thinghy on the IBM laptops. I never found using a mouse comfortable and the sound of repetitive clicking just drives me nuts.

The big selling points for me are:

1) no clicking sound

2) I don't have to let go of my pointing tool when typing on the keyboard

3) To move from upper left hand corner of left screen to lower right hand of right screen I just drop the pen in the right place on the tablet. I don't have to DRAG the bloody thing across my desk

On a down note, the quality of the pens has gone down as their design got better. One of my Wacoms is an intuos 2 and its pen still works great, but our intuos 4 pens are getting wobbly after 4 years of use...

Patrice Freymond

Editor  Certified Trainer FCP7/X
Post Consultant

Always learning...
@Patrice Freymond
by Kylee Wall
I hadn't thought about the click being gone. That's nice!

blog: kyleesportfolio.com/blog
twitter: @kyl33t
demo: kyleewall.com
Re: Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
by Dylan Reeve
I've never really come to grips (ha!) with a tablet. I've used them most for Photoshop stuff, and a fair bit with grading (before I had a proper control surface) but I actually find I get a really sore hand after any extended period of pen/tablet use.

The same is true of any more than a few minutes of actual writing with a pen and paper for me. I'm just not used to it - seriously. I've been using a keyboard and mouse as my primary method of writing since before I was ten - so maybe 25 years now?

For the last 18 years I've also worked full-time in front of a computer in one job or another. I've never had any obvious pain from mouse use, I think I've physically adapted.

That said - I'd like to get a tablet again sometime in the near future, I do certainly find them useful for some tasks in particular, but I don't see a tablet becoming my primary pointer anytime soon.

@Dylan Reeve
by Kylee Wall
When I write on paper with a pen, it hurts my hand after a while. But this setup didn't hurt me at all. I wonder if I'm just holding the (real) pen too hard to write or something.

I don't know, some ways of pointing are compatible or incompatible with people and I have no real insight as to why a person would like it or not. Worth trying if the opportunity presents itself, but not life-changing enough to seek one out.

blog: kyleesportfolio.com/blog
twitter: @kyl33t
demo: kyleewall.com
Re: Successes & Failures in Editing with a Wacom Pen Tablet
by Evan Schiff
Paul's grip shift is spot on. The pen becomes part of your hand, more or less.

Also, I find I don't ever have the problem of losing the pen. But I DO have the problem of stealing the pen. I get home and find that I put it in my pocket at some point. That's kinda become second nature, too. When I stand up, the pen goes in my pocket, and when I sit down at my desk again, it's right there for me. But yeah, that means it's also right there when I get home, and I just have to remember to bring it back to work with me!


Focusing on post-production, from editing and motion graphics to personal experiences and the psychology of being an editor.
Blog Feed  RSS


Archives:

July 2014 (1)
April 2014 (4)
March 2014 (1)
February 2014 (1)
December 2013 (1)
November 2013 (2)
October 2013 (2)
September 2013 (5)
August 2013 (3)
July 2013 (1)
June 2013 (1)
May 2013 (2)
April 2013 (10)
March 2013 (1)
January 2013 (1)
December 2012 (3)
November 2012 (3)
October 2012 (1)
September 2012 (6)
August 2012 (4)
July 2012 (1)
June 2012 (4)
May 2012 (3)
April 2012 (1)


Tags:

nab show (10)
video production (9)
editing (7)
independent film (5)
southeast creative summit (5)
video production conference (5)
post-production (4)
post production (4)
filmmaking (4)
Nab show (3)
video editing (3)
parenthood (3)
social media (2)
avid (2)
show more


FORUMSTUTORIALSFEATURESVIDEOSPODCASTSEVENTSSERVICESNEWSLETTERNEWSBLOGS

Creative COW LinkedIn Group Creative COW Facebook Page Creative COW on Twitter
© 2014 CreativeCOW.net All rights are reserved. - Privacy Policy

[Top]